← All posts

November 5, 2026 · 6 min read · Evansville

Pros and Cons of Living in Evansville, Wyoming

Wide North Platte River and bare cottonwoods under storm clouds east of Casper

The short answer

The pros of living in Evansville are about services and location: it's its own incorporated town on Casper's east side, with its own police department, fire department, animal control, public works and utility billing, and Casper is right there. The cons are practical: town zoning and permits apply, extra garbage pickup takes a phone call, and depending on the address, most shopping means a drive.

I'm keeping this about the place, not the people. Whether Evansville fits is about the house, the lot and the services you want. Our Evansville area page has an overview.

Alisha Collins is a REALTOR® in Casper, Wyoming who leads the Alisha Collins Real Estate Team, helping buyers and sellers across Casper and greater Wyoming.

How many homes are in Evansville, and what do they sell for?

The most recent state housing profile counts about 1,245 housing units in Evansville in 2019, up from 1,050 in 2010. Of those, 735 were single-family homes and about 33 percent were mobile homes. Of the occupied homes, 660 were owner-occupied and 441 were rented.

Those are Census survey estimates from the Wyoming Community Development Authority's Evansville profile, and they're several years old, so small-town numbers can be off. For what's actually for sale in Evansville right now, an agent with MLS access can pull it.

78 homes sold in Evansville from November 5, 2025 through November 5, 2026, at an average sale price of $309,447, according to the Wyoming MLS. The median was $306,500. That covers residential sales, including mobile and manufactured homes, and doesn't include farm and ranch properties or land. It's a town-wide average, not what a specific home is worth.

Pro: its own town government

Evansville isn't part of Casper. The Town of Evansville has a mayor and council, a municipal court, a planning and zoning function, and its own town ordinances. Town Hall is at 235 Curtis Street, and the office is open Monday through Friday, 8:00 am to 5:00 pm. The town's residents page describes Evansville as located directly to the north and east of Casper and part of the Casper metro area.

If you want a local office you can call about your street, that's a real plus.

Pro: police, fire and animal control in town

Evansville has its own police department and its own fire department, which the Town says has served the community since 1923. The Town also runs animal control. That's a full set of local services for a small town, and it's worth knowing who to call before you need them.

For homeowners insurance, ask your agent how a specific address rates. Distance to a fire station and hydrant access can affect a quote.

Pro: town utilities and a water fill station

The Town of Evansville has a Public Works department and handles utility billing, with an online bill pay link on its website. It publishes annual drinking water quality reports, so you can read the latest one before you buy.

There's also a town water fill station, with accounts set up through an online service linked from the Town's site. If you haul water for livestock or a cabin, that's handy.

Compare that with rural acreage outside town, where a well and septic system are on you. Our article on buying a home with well and septic explains what changes. My own first home with a well taught me plenty.

Pro: Casper next door, and the river nearby

Because Evansville sits on Casper's east side, Casper's employers, medical offices and stores are close. In this area we say there's no traffic and no real commute, and that's one of my favorite things about living here. Still, map the drive from the exact house to your work, your grocery store and your doctor before you decide. A few minutes either way adds up over a year.

The North Platte River runs through the area, too. If a home sits near the river, check its flood zone status before you buy.

Pro: the rules are easy to find

The Town of Evansville posts its ordinances through an online code library, and its permits and forms page has the zoning ordinance, the zoning map, and the zoning certificate. Forms can be mailed to the Town or faxed. That makes it easier to check a lot before you buy. If you're planning a fence, a garage or a shop, pull the zoning for the exact address and read it before you write an offer.

Con: extra garbage pickup takes a call

A small one, but good to know. The Town's FAQ says the extra pickup day for garbage is the second Tuesday of each month, and you must call for a pickup. If you're moving in with a pile of boxes, plan around that date or haul it yourself.

Con: town zoning and building paperwork

Evansville has a zoning ordinance, a zoning map, a zoning certificate form and sample plot plans on its permits and forms page. If you plan to build a shop, add a garage, put up a shed or run a business from home, read the zoning before you write an offer. A business license application is on the same page.

None of this is unusual. It's just paperwork you'll want to understand up front. When in doubt, write it down and ask the Town.

Con: errands usually mean a drive

Evansville is a small town. Depending on the address, big grocery runs and most appointments mean a drive into Casper. Check the exact house and map your regular errands before you decide. And plan for winter, because a short drive in January is still a winter drive. When you tour, look at the house with winter in mind: the age of the furnace, which way the driveway faces, and whether the garage fits your vehicles. Ask the seller for twelve months of gas and electric bills, and look hardest at December through February.

Con: real price data takes an agent

Wyoming is a non-disclosure state. Sold prices aren't public, and national website estimates aren't reliable here. An agent with MLS access can pull real closed sales for Evansville. That's a Wyoming thing, not an Evansville thing, but it surprises buyers from other states.

A note on schools and taxes

Evansville is in Natrona County School District #1, which offers School Choice. An address doesn't assign a school, so check the district's enrollment page for registration. Property taxes go through Natrona County. Read how property taxes work in Natrona County for the details. This is general information, not legal, tax, or lending advice.

Common questions

Is Evansville part of Casper?

No. Evansville is its own incorporated town on Casper's east side, with its own council, police, fire, animal control and public works.

When is extra garbage pickup in Evansville?

The Town's FAQ lists the second Tuesday of each month, and you must call to schedule a pickup.

Where do I find Evansville zoning rules?

The Town's permits, licenses and forms page has the zoning ordinance, zoning map, a zoning certificate and sample plot plans.

Does Evansville publish water quality reports?

Yes. The Town posts annual drinking water quality reports on its website.

Comparing Evansville with nearby towns?

Read Evansville vs. Mills and moving to Evansville, Wyoming, or see our relocation page if you're coming from out of state. When you want real listings and sold data, get in touch with our team.

Sources

The method

Where this fits in how we sell